@ARTICLE{TreeBASE2Ref29193,
author = {Ana Otero and Virginia Valcarcel and Pedro Jimenez-Mejias and Pablo Vargas},
title = {Being in the right place at the right moment? Parallel diversification bursts related to persistence of ancient epizoochorous traits and hidden factors in Cynoglossoideae},
year = {2019},
keywords = {Boraginaceae, Biogeography, diversification rates, HiSSE, hyperdiverse, phylogeny, trait-dependent reconstruction.},
doi = {},
url = {http://},
pmid = {},
journal = {American Journal of Botany},
volume = {},
number = {},
pages = {},
abstract = {Premise of the Study
Long-distance dispersal syndromes (LDD), especially endozoochory, facilitate plant colonization to new territories that trigger diversification. However, few studies have analyzed how epizoochorous fruits influence both range distribution and diversification rates. Here we examine the evolutionary history of a hyperdiverse clade of Boraginaceae (subfamily Cynoglossoideae, ~60 genera, ~1063 species) and the evolution of fruit traits. We evaluated the evolutionary history of diaspore syndromes as related to geographic distribution and diversification rates over time.
Methods
Plastid DNA regions and morphological traits associated with dispersal syndromes were analysed for 71 genera (226 species). We employed trait-dependent diversification analysis (HiSSE) and biogeographic reconstruction (Lagrange) using a time-calibrated phylogeny.
Key results
Our results indicate that: (i) the earliest divergence events in Cynoglossoideae occurred in the central-northeastern Palearctic during the Paleogene (early to mid-Eocene); (ii) an epizoochorous trait (specialized hooks named glochids) is ancestral and has been long-term maintained; and (iii) glochids are correlated with increased diversification rates in two distantly related clades (Rochelieae and Cynoglossinae). Rapid speciation occurred for these two groups in the same area (central-eastern Palearctic) and same period (Oligocene-Miocene: Rochelieae, 13.69-30.82 myr; Cynoglossinae, 15.21-33.10 myr). Lower diversification rates were inferred for the remaining four glochid-bearing clades.
Conclusions
One more example of biogeographic congruence in angiosperms is supported by a shared geographic (C-NE Palearctic) and temporal (28.60-21.59 myr, late Oligocene) opportunity window for two main clades diversification. Epizoochorous traits related to LDD (fruit glochids) are involved in higher diversification rates only with the joint effect of other unmeasured factors.
}
}
Taxa for matrix 49078 of Study 23831

Citation title:
"Being in the right place at the right moment? Parallel diversification bursts related to persistence of ancient epizoochorous traits and hidden factors in Cynoglossoideae".

Study name:
"Being in the right place at the right moment? Parallel diversification bursts related to persistence of ancient epizoochorous traits and hidden factors in Cynoglossoideae".

This study is part of submission 23831
(Status: Published).
Taxa
Return to matrix row view
ID |
Taxon Label |
NCBI taxid |
uBIO namebankID |
3517191 |
Actinocarya tibetica |
|
|
3517172 |
Amblynotus rupestris |
|
5892614
|
3517280 |
Amsinckia calycina |
|
5889012
|
3517183 |
Amsinckia menziesii |
|
458724
|
3517070 |
Amsinckia tessellata |
|
2654552
|
3517261 |
Amsinckia vernicosa |
255584
|
2654553
|
3517118 |
Anchusa formosana |
|
|
3517122 |
Antiotrema dunianum |
|
|
3517177 |
Antiphytum floribundum |
|
2654563
|
3517188 |
Antiphytum hintoniorum |
203729
|
5970356
|
3517224 |
Arnebia decumbens |
475885
|
1798407
|
3517199 |
Arnebia linearifolia |
554527
|
8641493
|
3517204 |
Asperugo procumbens |
|
2654565
|
3517181 |
Austrocynoglossum latifolium |
|
|
3517117 |
Borago officinalis |
13363
|
2654567
|
3517076 |
Bothriospermum kusnetzowii |
|
|
3517206 |
Bothriospermum tenellum |
363804
|
2654841
|
3517178 |
Brunnera macrophylla |
34249
|
2670796
|
3517121 |
Buglossoides incrassata |
475886
|
|
3517246 |
Caccinia macranthera |
|
|
3517147 |
Cerinthe majus |
|
|
3517074 |
Cordia decandra |
246522
|
5830976
|
3517112 |
Cordia monoica |
222084
|
5972474
|
3517193 |
Cryptantha decipens |
|
|
3517081 |
Cryptantha granulosa |
|
8613973
|
3517085 |
Cryptantha johnstonii |
|
|
3517082 |
Cryptantha paradoxa |
|
|
3517094 |
Cryptantha peruviana |
543568
|
8614126
|
3517151 |
Cryptantha pterocarya |
543569
|
2654675
|
3517144 |
Cynoglossum amabile |
354628
|
2654703
|
3517141 |
Cynoglossum amplifolium |
256486
|
5976247
|
3517096 |
Cynoglossum australe |
|
|
3517200 |
Cynoglossum clandestinum |
|
|
3517119 |
Cynoglossum columnae |
|
|
3517078 |
Cynoglossum creticum |
363801
|
5925061
|
3517243 |
Cynoglossum dioscoridis |
|
|
3517282 |
Cynoglossum germanicum |
0
|
5925063
|
3517063 |
Cynoglossum grande |
|
|
3517138 |
Cynoglossum hispidum |
|
|
3517238 |
Cynoglossum hungaricum |
|
|
3517066 |
Cynoglossum montanum |
|
|
3517089 |
Cynoglossum nebrodense |
|
|
3517083 |
Cynoglossum occidentale |
|
458875
|
3517129 |
Cynoglossum officinale |
181189
|
2654706
|
3517241 |
Cynoglossum paniculatum |
|
|
3517277 |
Cynoglossum spelaeum |
|
8624945
|
3517134 |
Cynoglossum sphacioticum |
|
|
3517109 |
Cynoglossum suaveolens |
|
|
3517168 |
Cynoglossum troodi |
|
|
3517145 |
Cynoglossum virginianum |
|
2654707
|
3517176 |
Dasynotus daubenmirei |
|
|
3517274 |
Echiochilon fruticosum |
227953
|
5973137
|
3517229 |
Echium acanthocarpum |
362696
|
10296749
|
3517184 |
Echium creticum |
113431
|
2666811
|
3517270 |
Echium vulgare |
34253
|
2654713
|
3517102 |
Ehretia anacua |
99303
|
2654715
|
3517267 |
Ehretia cortesia |
263603
|
5977194
|
3517228 |
Embadium stagnense |
|
|
3517148 |
Embadium uncinatum |
|
|
3517263 |
Eremocarya micrantha |
|
|
3517256 |
Eritrichium aretioides |
669689
|
2780614
|
3517064 |
Eritrichium canum |
0
|
8635683
|
3517166 |
Eritrichium nanum |
184082
|
2654718
|
3517152 |
Eritrichium pamiricum |
|
|
3517167 |
Eritrichium pectinatociliatum |
|
|
3517080 |
Eritrichium sericeum |
488675
|
8610822
|
3517086 |
Eritrichium thymifolium |
|
|
3517143 |
Glandora nitida |
475894
|
|
3517100 |
Gyrocaryum oppositifolium |
|
|
3517202 |
Hackelia andicola |
|
|
3517163 |
Hackelia bella |
|
|
3517175 |
Hackelia deflexa |
0
|
2654726
|
3517067 |
Hackelia floribunda |
|
458910
|
3517091 |
Hackelia revoluta |
|
|
3517072 |
Hackelia sharsmithii |
|
|
3517073 |
Hackelia velutina |
|
|
3517104 |
Harpagonella palmeri |
|
2654747
|
3517131 |
Heterocaryum subsessile |
|
|
3517262 |
Huynhia pulchra |
554533
|
10565277
|
3517174 |
Johnstonella angustifolia |
|
|
3517222 |
Lappula alatavica |
|
|
3517221 |
Lappula anocarpa |
|
8655939
|
3517212 |
Lappula balchaschensis |
|
|
3517258 |
Lappula brachycentra |
|
|
3517108 |
Lappula cenchrusoides |
|
|
3517231 |
Lappula consanguinea |
|
|
3517065 |
Lappula duplicicarpa |
|
|
3517069 |
Lappula intermedia |
|
|
3517132 |
Lappula lasiocarpa |
|
|
3517171 |
Lappula lipsky |
|
|
3517223 |
Lappula marginata |
|
|
3517190 |
Lappula microcarpa |
|
|
3517135 |
Lappula myosotis |
|
|
3517214 |
Lappula occidentalis |
|
2667741
|
3517095 |
Lappula occultata |
|
|
3517170 |
Lappula patula |
|
|
3517071 |
Lappula semiglabra |
|
|
3517182 |
Lappula sessiliflora |
|
8637564
|
3517259 |
Lappula spinocarpa |
|
|
3517157 |
Lappula squarrosa |
203740
|
2667742
|
3517232 |
Lappula stricta |
|
|
3517201 |
Lappula tadshikorum |
|
|
3517244 |
Lappula tenuis |
|
|
3517252 |
Lappula texana |
|
2782843
|
3517087 |
Lasiocaryum densiflorum |
|
|
3517180 |
Lasiocaryum munroi |
|
8656446
|
3517090 |
Lepechiniella microcarpa |
|
|
3517185 |
Lindelofia anchusoides |
|
|
3517084 |
Lindelofia longiflora |
203742
|
5884964
|
3517260 |
Lindelofia stylosa |
|
|
3517286 |
Lithospermum macbridei |
650309
|
5842828
|
3517195 |
Lithospermum officinale |
475907
|
2654762
|
3517197 |
Lithospermum persicum |
|
|
3517150 |
Mairetis microsperma |
475912
|
10565871
|
3517248 |
Memoremea scorpioides |
|
|
3517107 |
Mertensia ciliata |
|
2654527
|
3517205 |
Mertensia davurica |
|
8611012
|
3517245 |
Mertensia lanceolata |
|
2654535
|
3517269 |
Mertensia maritima |
669721
|
2654521
|
3517254 |
Mertensia sibirica |
|
3411577
|
3517215 |
Metaeritrichium microuloides |
|
|
3517165 |
Microparacaryum intermedium |
|
|
3517130 |
Microula blepharolepis |
|
|
3517092 |
Microula diffusa |
|
|
3517153 |
Microula floribunda |
|
|
3517116 |
Microula muliensis |
|
|
3517106 |
Microula myosotidea |
|
|
3517113 |
Microula oblongifolia |
|
|
3517211 |
Microula ovalifolia |
|
|
3517097 |
Microula pustulosa |
|
|
3517240 |
Microula sikkimensis |
694029
|
8654102
|
3517281 |
Microula stenophylla |
|
|
3517142 |
Microula tibetica |
|
8654766
|
3517187 |
Microula trichocarpa |
|
|
3517179 |
Microula turbinata |
|
|
3517273 |
Microula younghusbandii |
|
|
3517242 |
Moltkia petraea |
475914
|
5884912
|
3517139 |
Moritzia lindenii |
0
|
8616091
|
3517126 |
Myosotidium hortensia |
192332
|
5845341
|
3517133 |
Myosotis alpestris |
192337
|
2771432
|
3517225 |
Myosotis caespitosa |
0
|
8609899
|
3517276 |
Myosotis incrassata |
192352
|
5925220
|
3517115 |
Myosotis macrosperma |
192355
|
2654545
|
3517137 |
Myosotis sparsiflora |
0
|
5925277
|
3517284 |
Myosotis stenophylla |
|
|
3517253 |
Myosotis stolonifera |
0
|
5925283
|
3517272 |
Nihon japonicum |
|
|
3517271 |
Nonea caspica |
291677
|
5925305
|
3517077 |
Omphalodes akiensis |
|
|
3517159 |
Omphalodes aliena |
|
2654771
|
3517068 |
Omphalodes alienoides |
|
|
3517125 |
Omphalodes brassicifolia |
317959
|
5925319
|
3517196 |
Omphalodes cappadocica |
|
5917349
|
3517226 |
Omphalodes cardiophylla |
|
|
3517233 |
Omphalodes caucasica |
|
|
3517213 |
Omphalodes commutata |
317958
|
10269134
|
3517140 |
Omphalodes kuzinskyanae |
317955
|
5925321
|
3517160 |
Omphalodes linifolia |
317957
|
2668324
|
3517239 |
Omphalodes littoralis |
317961
|
5925323
|
3517217 |
Omphalodes nitida |
317960
|
5925325
|
3517110 |
Omphalodes verna |
203754
|
2668325
|
3517264 |
Omphalolappula concava |
|
|
3517255 |
Onosma rhodopea |
650324
|
5925373
|
3517257 |
Oreocarya flavoculata |
|
|
3517161 |
Oreocarya suffruticosa |
|
2784870
|
3517098 |
Paracaryum ancyritanum |
|
|
3517124 |
Paracaryum cappadocicum |
|
|
3517203 |
Paracaryum laxiflorum |
|
|
3517266 |
Paracaryum polycarpum |
|
|
3517120 |
Paracaryum racemosum |
|
5865702
|
3517136 |
Paracaryum rugulosum |
|
|
3517275 |
Pardoglossum cheirifolium |
203756
|
5970361
|
3517114 |
Pardoglossum watieri |
|
|
3517101 |
Pectocarya lateriflora |
|
|
3517186 |
Pectocarya penicillata |
|
474990
|
3517075 |
Pectocarya setosa |
|
2654782
|
3517198 |
Pentaglottis sempervirens |
203760
|
2654784
|
3517192 |
Phacelia campanularia |
79382
|
2654351
|
3517099 |
Phacelia sericea |
79541
|
2654464
|
3517088 |
Plagiobothrys congestus |
|
8616201
|
3517236 |
Plagiobothrys fulvus |
|
|
3517154 |
Plagiobothrys humilis |
0
|
8622181
|
3517210 |
Plagiobothrys kunthii |
|
|
3517268 |
Plagiobothrys linifolius |
|
8648361
|
3517149 |
Plagiobothrys myosotoides |
|
458981
|
3517249 |
Pseudomertensia primuloides |
|
10566890
|
3517146 |
Pseudomertensia trollii |
|
10566893
|
3517251 |
Pulmonaria angustifolia |
256499
|
1672948
|
3517173 |
Rindera caespitosa |
|
|
3517285 |
Rindera graeca |
|
|
3517235 |
Rindera lanata |
|
|
3517093 |
Rindera schlumbergeri |
|
|
3517208 |
Rindera tetraspis |
|
|
3517128 |
Rochelia cancellata |
|
10567009
|
3517234 |
Rochelia cardiosepala |
|
8640557
|
3517164 |
Rochelia persica |
|
8640667
|
3517123 |
Rochelia retorta |
|
|
3517209 |
Sinojohnstonia moupinensis |
|
|
3517219 |
Solenanthus albiflorus |
|
|
3517218 |
Solenanthus apenninus |
|
5925441
|
3517156 |
Solenanthus atlanticus |
|
|
3517247 |
Solenanthus circinatus |
|
8640746
|
3517189 |
Solenanthus coronatus |
|
|
3517227 |
Solenanthus hirsutus |
|
|
3517111 |
Solenanthus karateginus |
|
|
3517250 |
Solenanthus tubiflorus |
|
|
3517162 |
Solenanthus turkestanicus |
|
|
3517287 |
Stephanocaryum olgae |
|
|
3517194 |
Suchtelenia calycina |
|
|
3517127 |
Thyrocarpus glochidiatum |
|
|
3517230 |
Tournefortia hirsutissima |
168368
|
2654831
|
3517155 |
Tournefortia ternifolia |
244119
|
5974951
|
3517062 |
Trachelanthus cerinthoides |
|
|
3517220 |
Trachelanthus hissaricus |
|
|
3517237 |
Trachystemon orientalis |
256506
|
5857752
|
3517207 |
Trichodesma africana |
|
|
3517216 |
Trichodesma calcaratum |
|
|
3517278 |
Trichodesma calycosum |
|
|
3517283 |
Trichodesma physaloides |
|
|
3517103 |
Trichodesma zeylanicum |
0
|
5857797
|
3517158 |
Trigonocaryum involucratum |
|
5858033
|
3517169 |
Trigonotis amblyosepala |
|
8651983
|
3517105 |
Trigonotis formosana |
0
|
8651324
|
3517265 |
Trigonotis guilielmi |
|
5858036
|
3517279 |
Trigonotis jinfoshanica |
|
|
3517079 |
Trigonotis peduncularis |
203766
|
2669666
|